Recently, my classmate Skylar T posted an article comparing the effects of Barack Obama and Donald Trump in office. I'd like to respond to it by pointing out what I think are some factual inaccuracies.
First, I think that this argument is a relatively weak argument, because there are many people who take Mr. Trump seriously. I know that whether or not one takes him seriously is a personal opinion, and not a factual inaccuracy, but I thought I should point that out.
On the topic of incorrect facts within this post, the most major is the statement that "The only thing Trump is worried about is immigrants." This is a false claim, and there are no facts to back it up. In fact, there are facts that prove the opposite. For example, since Mr. Trump was elected, the economy has been doing very well. Also, the unemployment rate is lower than it has been in 49 years. To say that he focuses on nothing but immigrants is largely erroneous.
Another thing that I would like to reflect upon is the rhetorical statement to the readers to "Name one President who was able to do this." It is unclear whether this means name a President who could make fun of people or if it means name a President who had influence after leaving the office. Either way, there are many examples of Presidents who had influence post-office or made fun of other people (though the quality of making fun of people usually is not a desirable trait of a leader , or anybody.....yes, I know that Mr. Trump does this quite often, however I am not defending everything he does, just stating some facts.) For example, Jimmy Carter and George H. W. Bush went on for many years to speak, lecture, and volunteer, and had a rather big influence on many things. For the alternative meaning of the rhetorical statement, there have been quite a few incidents throughout history of presidents insulting former presidents and other staff members. For example, Andrew Jackson said that he regretted that he had not yet "shot Henry Clay" or "hanged John Calhoun," and LBJ said that Gerald Ford was "so dumb that he can't fart and chew gum at the same time." Harry Truman even called Richard Nixon "a no good lying bastard." (History.com)
I thought that the factual inaccuracies needed to be addressed, and that was the purpose of this critique. I do also think that there are some good parts of this article, like the point raised about how many people call out Mr. Trump all the time (whether or not they are right in doing so is an entirely different issue altogether) and how people tend to be childish in conversations concerning Mr. Trump.
No comments:
Post a Comment