In this blog post, I would like to respond to my classmate Madison Mann's latest post. In her article, she writes about President Trump and his policies regarding the military and transgender citizens.
There are a lot of things in this article that I would like to comment about. The first of these is that this "ban" is technically a ban, but it is really just a return to the way this country has always treated this issue. Until June 2016, never in American history have transgender people been allowed in the military. President Obama changed that as one of his final acts in office. All that Mr. Trump is doing is reversing it.
Secondly, as Madison states in her article, people who "suffer from the condition known as 'gender dysphoria'" are banned from armed service, which really is the way it has always been, and that makes sense. People with gender dysphoria typically have far higher rates of depression and suicide, and are also far more likely to have other mental problems. For this reason, it does not seem like a great idea to give guns to people who suffer from this. If I were in the military, no offense, I would prefer to have a wingman or a cover who was mentally stable.
Although it is a little unclear, based on Mann's article, what Noel Francisco and his court cases are going to do, and what side he is on, I think the point of this part of Mann's article is to say that there are efforts to make the ban permanent. If you ask me, that is probably a good idea. The culture of the military should not be based off of the whims of society, where people now can reject the gender that they are from birth, that their DNA and chromosomes and their genes make them to be. Either you have male parts or female parts. It is literally as simple as that. One or the other. there is no need for all the confusion and complication and heartache that have come from society's latest whim. The military is supposed to be strong and secure and steady. If this ban is lifted, the ability of the military to be those things that it needs to be will diminish.
The last comment I'd like to make is about Nancy Pelosi. According to Mann's post, Pelosi says that President Trump "designed this ban to humiliate transgender Americans." What this means is that the reason that Mr. Trump enacted this ban is to humiliate people. Why in the world would he do that? It does not make sense, it is not logical, and it certainly would be cruel. This is why I am certain that humiliation was not his intent. The other reason I am sure of this, which is much more concrete than the first, is that Trump definitely did not say he wanted to humiliate people. In fact, there are absolutely no facts that support what Pelosi says. (All of what Mann quotes from Pelosi, and what she says about the ban at the beginning of her post are un-cited, direct quotes from a CNN news article on the subject.) This CNN article gives zero factual support for Pelosi's statement. I have read many other articles on the subject, and have yet to find any proof of what Pelosi said.
According to the Washington Post,
Obama's act actually gives transgender people money for "sex
reassignment surgery." So, that is what taxpayer money is going to.
That is not right. Why should tax money have to go to that? If somebody wants to cut off part of their body and pretend to be something that they are not, the government should not have to pay for it. I think that Mr. Trump is doing a good thing by trying to reverse Obama's act.
Friday, December 14, 2018
Saturday, December 1, 2018
Thoughts on the Migrant Caravan
I have been hearing a lot recently about the "migrant caravan" on the news, and have seen headlines and articles voicing lots of opinions. I would like to present my thoughts on this. A side note, before I start, is this: I am not saying that people are wrong for trying to come into America. I am merely going to comment on the reactions of other people.
The first thing that I want to bring up is Mr. Trump. People have been trash talking Mr. Trump for what he has said concerning the caravan. He has stated that there are likely bad people in the caravan. The media attacked him for this, and said that he was just assuming the worst. But, actually, he is just stating what is likely true. As the New York Post's John Crudele so adequately puts it, "what are the odds there aren’t some terrorists or drug cartel members in the crowd of 7,000 people in the caravan?" To answer his question, the odds are very, very low. In fact, according to a Fox News report today, the odds are zero. The article proves that there is at least one person who probably should not be allowed into the country. The name of the article is "MS-13 gang member caught traveling with migrant caravan." That pretty much takes care of John Crudele's question. The media definitely needs to lighten up on President Trump about that one.
Next, I would like to mention the fact that the caravan is being stopped at the border. A lot of Americans are upset that people are not being ushered into America. They think that it is not right for immigrants to be stopped, and seem shocked that this is happening. However, they should not be shocked, because that is the law of the land. The law does not just change like this. If the law is unjust, then it should be changed through the legislative process. Another group of people who is upset over the caravan being stopped at the border is the city of Tijuana. The city is losing 30-40 thousand dollars a day housing all of the caravan members there, and the mayor is not happy about it. According to Fox News, he says there will be no more funding for the caravan, and has given the order to arrest the organizer of the caravan. The city "lost 129 million pesos" while the border was closed for 6 hours on Sunday (Fox News). The people in the caravan have absolutely no right to do that to the city of Tijuana and its 1.7 million taxpayers.
I think that the people who are stating their opinions on these things should look at the facts before they say anything, because then they might end up looking foolish for saying there is no way to know if there are bad people in the caravan that has been proven to have bad people in it (MS-13). They need to look at the situation and see what the reality is before they trash talk anybody else for being correct.
Friday, November 16, 2018
RE: "Obama vs Trump"
Recently, my classmate Skylar T posted an article comparing the effects of Barack Obama and Donald Trump in office. I'd like to respond to it by pointing out what I think are some factual inaccuracies.
First, I think that this argument is a relatively weak argument, because there are many people who take Mr. Trump seriously. I know that whether or not one takes him seriously is a personal opinion, and not a factual inaccuracy, but I thought I should point that out.
On the topic of incorrect facts within this post, the most major is the statement that "The only thing Trump is worried about is immigrants." This is a false claim, and there are no facts to back it up. In fact, there are facts that prove the opposite. For example, since Mr. Trump was elected, the economy has been doing very well. Also, the unemployment rate is lower than it has been in 49 years. To say that he focuses on nothing but immigrants is largely erroneous.
Another thing that I would like to reflect upon is the rhetorical statement to the readers to "Name one President who was able to do this." It is unclear whether this means name a President who could make fun of people or if it means name a President who had influence after leaving the office. Either way, there are many examples of Presidents who had influence post-office or made fun of other people (though the quality of making fun of people usually is not a desirable trait of a leader , or anybody.....yes, I know that Mr. Trump does this quite often, however I am not defending everything he does, just stating some facts.) For example, Jimmy Carter and George H. W. Bush went on for many years to speak, lecture, and volunteer, and had a rather big influence on many things. For the alternative meaning of the rhetorical statement, there have been quite a few incidents throughout history of presidents insulting former presidents and other staff members. For example, Andrew Jackson said that he regretted that he had not yet "shot Henry Clay" or "hanged John Calhoun," and LBJ said that Gerald Ford was "so dumb that he can't fart and chew gum at the same time." Harry Truman even called Richard Nixon "a no good lying bastard." (History.com)
I thought that the factual inaccuracies needed to be addressed, and that was the purpose of this critique. I do also think that there are some good parts of this article, like the point raised about how many people call out Mr. Trump all the time (whether or not they are right in doing so is an entirely different issue altogether) and how people tend to be childish in conversations concerning Mr. Trump.
First, I think that this argument is a relatively weak argument, because there are many people who take Mr. Trump seriously. I know that whether or not one takes him seriously is a personal opinion, and not a factual inaccuracy, but I thought I should point that out.
On the topic of incorrect facts within this post, the most major is the statement that "The only thing Trump is worried about is immigrants." This is a false claim, and there are no facts to back it up. In fact, there are facts that prove the opposite. For example, since Mr. Trump was elected, the economy has been doing very well. Also, the unemployment rate is lower than it has been in 49 years. To say that he focuses on nothing but immigrants is largely erroneous.
Another thing that I would like to reflect upon is the rhetorical statement to the readers to "Name one President who was able to do this." It is unclear whether this means name a President who could make fun of people or if it means name a President who had influence after leaving the office. Either way, there are many examples of Presidents who had influence post-office or made fun of other people (though the quality of making fun of people usually is not a desirable trait of a leader , or anybody.....yes, I know that Mr. Trump does this quite often, however I am not defending everything he does, just stating some facts.) For example, Jimmy Carter and George H. W. Bush went on for many years to speak, lecture, and volunteer, and had a rather big influence on many things. For the alternative meaning of the rhetorical statement, there have been quite a few incidents throughout history of presidents insulting former presidents and other staff members. For example, Andrew Jackson said that he regretted that he had not yet "shot Henry Clay" or "hanged John Calhoun," and LBJ said that Gerald Ford was "so dumb that he can't fart and chew gum at the same time." Harry Truman even called Richard Nixon "a no good lying bastard." (History.com)
I thought that the factual inaccuracies needed to be addressed, and that was the purpose of this critique. I do also think that there are some good parts of this article, like the point raised about how many people call out Mr. Trump all the time (whether or not they are right in doing so is an entirely different issue altogether) and how people tend to be childish in conversations concerning Mr. Trump.
Friday, October 26, 2018
The Media...is it "Fake News" or not?
Recently, there have been many news stories, articles, and discussions in the media concerning Donald Trump and his performance as President. The trend, as my experience watching the news and scrolling through my computer's homepage, is to criticize everything that President Trump has done without giving him much credit for anything good that he accomplishes.
In press conferences that Trump has held, the reporters are relentless. The majority of them target him with their questions, trying to trap him into sounding like 'the bad guy'. While watching the conference live, it is strikingly obvious that this is what is occurring. However, on the news the following evening, the headlines are all about the awful things that Mr. Trump said, which aren't exactly true. An example of this that comes to mind is a press conference that he held during the issues surrounding Judge Kavanaugh. As I was watching the conference, I noticed the headlines at the bottom of the TV screen. Even as he was talking, whoever was writing the headlines was taking things that Mr. Trump said, then removing them from all context, and writing them in a way that indicated that the President was saying some terrible things. For example: a reporter asked is he thought the Kavanaugh accuser's claims were false, and he said "I don't know, they may be false claims, but we won't know until we hear them tomorrow." A few seconds later, the bold letters at the bottom of the screen read "Trump: the women's claims are 'false claims' ". I was appalled at how quickly his words were being twisted against him in inaccurate ways. The news that night did the same things, only playing small, out of context clips of the conference to make it look like President Trump said thing that he did not say, making him look bad to their viewers.
Additionally, President Trump has actually made some impressive achievements. He has done very well with the national economy, and the unemployment rate is the lowest it has been in 49 years. But, this is never reported. Sometimes these issues are reported on, like how low the unemployment rate is, but the media rarely gives the President any credit, even though he has a lot to do with it.
The media reports things about the President that make him look bad. When he does good things, it is all but absent from mainstream media. I have noticed that President Trump is aware of this. I have seen him comment on it, and I think this is part of why he calls the media "fake news". I think that he is more right than he is wrong about this. The news really does make him seem like a bad guy in situations where he is not, and they leave him out when they should call him a good guy. This leads me to my conclusion; that the media concerning President Trump is largely "fake news".
In press conferences that Trump has held, the reporters are relentless. The majority of them target him with their questions, trying to trap him into sounding like 'the bad guy'. While watching the conference live, it is strikingly obvious that this is what is occurring. However, on the news the following evening, the headlines are all about the awful things that Mr. Trump said, which aren't exactly true. An example of this that comes to mind is a press conference that he held during the issues surrounding Judge Kavanaugh. As I was watching the conference, I noticed the headlines at the bottom of the TV screen. Even as he was talking, whoever was writing the headlines was taking things that Mr. Trump said, then removing them from all context, and writing them in a way that indicated that the President was saying some terrible things. For example: a reporter asked is he thought the Kavanaugh accuser's claims were false, and he said "I don't know, they may be false claims, but we won't know until we hear them tomorrow." A few seconds later, the bold letters at the bottom of the screen read "Trump: the women's claims are 'false claims' ". I was appalled at how quickly his words were being twisted against him in inaccurate ways. The news that night did the same things, only playing small, out of context clips of the conference to make it look like President Trump said thing that he did not say, making him look bad to their viewers.
Additionally, President Trump has actually made some impressive achievements. He has done very well with the national economy, and the unemployment rate is the lowest it has been in 49 years. But, this is never reported. Sometimes these issues are reported on, like how low the unemployment rate is, but the media rarely gives the President any credit, even though he has a lot to do with it.
The media reports things about the President that make him look bad. When he does good things, it is all but absent from mainstream media. I have noticed that President Trump is aware of this. I have seen him comment on it, and I think this is part of why he calls the media "fake news". I think that he is more right than he is wrong about this. The news really does make him seem like a bad guy in situations where he is not, and they leave him out when they should call him a good guy. This leads me to my conclusion; that the media concerning President Trump is largely "fake news".
Friday, October 19, 2018
Tammy Bruce on Elizabeth Warren and the Democrats
Yesterday, Tammy Bruce published an article that stated her thoughts on recent events in government, including the issue involving Elizabeth Warren's DNA. She says that many of the current problems and unrest in our government originate with the Democratic Party, which is not trying to improve the country...instead it is only distracting their voters from the fact that the country is actually doing quite well right now, thanks to President Trump. "One of the reasons you don't hear about the president's legislative, policy, and leadership success touted in the media is because they're covering the mobs and the chaos brought to you by the Democrats." In this very well put statement, Bruce acknowledges the President's real successes, and gives a legitimate reason for why the media never covers any of them. According to Bruce, the Democrats in government have forgotten what it means to care about their constituents and their country because they only care about themselves. However, some Democrats have seen this for what it is, and spoken out about it. For example: when Elizabeth Warren's DNA test results were released, Democrat Jim Messina (Former Obama campaign manager) responded by asking,"...why 22 days before a crucial election where we MUST win house and senate to save America, why did @SenWarren have to do her announcement now? Why can't Dems ever stay focused???" Another example of the "Democratic mob" in action was recently when they attempted to ruin Justice Brett Kavanaugh. But, according to Bruce, that "was only the beginning." I think That Bruce makes a strong argument in this article. She is logical and clear, and her opinion, at least to me, seems to be correct. She made her claim and supported it, even though some people may disagree with her and say that she is hugely mistaken. This article was bravely and timely written, as she may receive some backlash for her opinion, and because the elections are very close. Overall, I would say that Bruce is correct in what she says, and that more people should read her article, because it might shed some new light on this topic for them.
Friday, October 5, 2018
Doug Schoen on Brett Kavanaugh
Doug Schoen of Fox News recently published an article on the Fox website expressing his opinion about what the confirmation of Brett Kavanaugh could mean for the future of the Republican Party after the November elections. In this article, Schoen states that recent events surrounding Judge Kavanaugh could alienate women from wanting to vote Republican in November, even if they were Republican before.
Schoen makes the claim that women will be less likely to vote Republican after a man who was accused of assaulting three women was confirmed and supported by many Republicans. According to Schoen, "if...women conclude that the Republican Party is more concerned about protecting men accused of sexual misconduct than protecting women", then the "gender gap will expand further" (there is already a "12 point margin of women favoring Democratic candidates").
Throughout his article, Schoen presents his opinion of what will happen very logically, and makes sure he presents the facts to support what he says. Even if somebody does not agree with him, nobody is justified to be angry with him because he is very clear about what he means with his writing, and is basing his opinion on facts, not biases. Near the end of his article, he even states, plainly and simply, that he "writes this not as an ideologue or a partisan" and that he instead presents this "as someone who has been closely involved in studying and working in political campaigns for decades". Schoen not only makes a logical, unbiased claim...he also justifies his action in doing so and provides proof that he is knowledgeable in this field, which says that his opinion can be trusted.
Overall, I think that Schoen's article was written well, had much to support it, and makes a very good case for Schoen's opinion of the upcoming elections.
Schoen makes the claim that women will be less likely to vote Republican after a man who was accused of assaulting three women was confirmed and supported by many Republicans. According to Schoen, "if...women conclude that the Republican Party is more concerned about protecting men accused of sexual misconduct than protecting women", then the "gender gap will expand further" (there is already a "12 point margin of women favoring Democratic candidates").
Throughout his article, Schoen presents his opinion of what will happen very logically, and makes sure he presents the facts to support what he says. Even if somebody does not agree with him, nobody is justified to be angry with him because he is very clear about what he means with his writing, and is basing his opinion on facts, not biases. Near the end of his article, he even states, plainly and simply, that he "writes this not as an ideologue or a partisan" and that he instead presents this "as someone who has been closely involved in studying and working in political campaigns for decades". Schoen not only makes a logical, unbiased claim...he also justifies his action in doing so and provides proof that he is knowledgeable in this field, which says that his opinion can be trusted.
Overall, I think that Schoen's article was written well, had much to support it, and makes a very good case for Schoen's opinion of the upcoming elections.
Friday, September 21, 2018
Hurricane Maria Aid Issues
On Friday, September 21st, a CNN article was published about US involvement with Hurricane Maria cleanup in Puerto Rico. The main argument of the article is that the United States "aid" was not very helpful or productive. In the article, it is stated that after the earthquake in Haiti in 2010 there were "22,000 troops, more than 30 ships and some 300 helicopters" to help cleanup. In contrast, the US only flew "5,373 sorties" (flights) to Puerto Rico for Maria.
Another big issue was is that the US and FEMA were so delayed in providing clean water and other supplies to Puerto Rico, that by the time they actually got there, it was too late, and people were already sick from drinking bad water, and there was clean water from other places. Now, there are "millions of bottles of water" sitting on an airport runway wasting in the sun. The head of FEMA admitted that "any time FEMA is the first responder and the primary responder like we were in Puerto Rico, it's never an ideal situation."
This article is a good read, because it bring up some points and facts that are not well known, but definitely should be. It also raises relevant questions that need to be asked. For example: Why did Haiti, Texas, and Florida receive good aid and supplies while some places in Puerto Rico suffered for weeks without help? And how, after the colossal mess in Puerto Rico and his previous quote, can the FEMA head still say, "I do believe that we kept that island from complete and total collapse."?
Another big issue was is that the US and FEMA were so delayed in providing clean water and other supplies to Puerto Rico, that by the time they actually got there, it was too late, and people were already sick from drinking bad water, and there was clean water from other places. Now, there are "millions of bottles of water" sitting on an airport runway wasting in the sun. The head of FEMA admitted that "any time FEMA is the first responder and the primary responder like we were in Puerto Rico, it's never an ideal situation."
This article is a good read, because it bring up some points and facts that are not well known, but definitely should be. It also raises relevant questions that need to be asked. For example: Why did Haiti, Texas, and Florida receive good aid and supplies while some places in Puerto Rico suffered for weeks without help? And how, after the colossal mess in Puerto Rico and his previous quote, can the FEMA head still say, "I do believe that we kept that island from complete and total collapse."?
Weir, Bill. “What Really Happened in Puerto Rico after Maria.” CNN, Cable News Network, 21 Sept. 2018, www.cnn.com/2018/09/21/us/puerto-rico-hurricane-maria-natural-disaster-human-catastrophe-weir/index.html.
Friday, September 7, 2018
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)