In this blog post, I would like to respond to my classmate Madison Mann's latest post. In her article, she writes about President Trump and his policies regarding the military and transgender citizens.
There are a lot of things in this article that I would like to comment about. The first of these is that this "ban" is technically a ban, but it is really just a return to the way this country has always treated this issue. Until June 2016, never in American history have transgender people been allowed in the military. President Obama changed that as one of his final acts in office. All that Mr. Trump is doing is reversing it.
Secondly, as Madison states in her article, people who "suffer from the condition known as 'gender dysphoria'" are banned from armed service, which really is the way it has always been, and that makes sense. People with gender dysphoria typically have far higher rates of depression and suicide, and are also far more likely to have other mental problems. For this reason, it does not seem like a great idea to give guns to people who suffer from this. If I were in the military, no offense, I would prefer to have a wingman or a cover who was mentally stable.
Although it is a little unclear, based on Mann's article, what Noel Francisco and his court cases are going to do, and what side he is on, I think the point of this part of Mann's article is to say that there are efforts to make the ban permanent. If you ask me, that is probably a good idea. The culture of the military should not be based off of the whims of society, where people now can reject the gender that they are from birth, that their DNA and chromosomes and their genes make them to be. Either you have male parts or female parts. It is literally as simple as that. One or the other. there is no need for all the confusion and complication and heartache that have come from society's latest whim. The military is supposed to be strong and secure and steady. If this ban is lifted, the ability of the military to be those things that it needs to be will diminish.
The last comment I'd like to make is about Nancy Pelosi. According to Mann's post, Pelosi says that President Trump "designed this ban to humiliate transgender Americans." What this means is that the reason that Mr. Trump enacted this ban is to humiliate people. Why in the world would he do that? It does not make sense, it is not logical, and it certainly would be cruel. This is why I am certain that humiliation was not his intent. The other reason I am sure of this, which is much more concrete than the first, is that Trump definitely did not say he wanted to humiliate people. In fact, there are absolutely no facts that support what Pelosi says. (All of what Mann quotes from Pelosi, and what she says about the ban at the beginning of her post are un-cited, direct quotes from a CNN news article on the subject.) This CNN article gives zero factual support for Pelosi's statement. I have read many other articles on the subject, and have yet to find any proof of what Pelosi said.
According to the Washington Post,
Obama's act actually gives transgender people money for "sex
reassignment surgery." So, that is what taxpayer money is going to.
That is not right. Why should tax money have to go to that? If somebody wants to cut off part of their body and pretend to be something that they are not, the government should not have to pay for it. I think that Mr. Trump is doing a good thing by trying to reverse Obama's act.
No comments:
Post a Comment