Saturday, December 1, 2018

Thoughts on the Migrant Caravan


      I have been hearing a lot recently about the "migrant caravan" on the news, and have seen headlines and articles voicing lots of opinions. I would like to present my thoughts on this. A side note, before I start, is this: I am not saying that people are wrong for trying to come into America. I am merely going to comment on the reactions of other people.
       The first thing that I want to bring up is Mr. Trump. People have been trash talking Mr. Trump for what he has said concerning the caravan. He has stated that there are likely bad people in the caravan. The media attacked him for this, and said that he was just assuming the worst. But, actually, he is just stating what is likely true. As the New York Post's John Crudele so adequately puts it, "what are the odds there aren’t some terrorists or drug cartel members in the crowd of 7,000 people in the caravan?" To answer his question, the odds are very, very low. In fact, according to a Fox News report today, the odds are zero. The article proves that there is at least one person who probably should not be allowed into the country. The name of the article is "MS-13 gang member caught traveling with migrant caravan." That pretty much takes care of John Crudele's question. The media definitely needs to lighten up on President Trump about that one.
      Next, I would like to mention the fact that the caravan is being stopped at the border. A lot of Americans are upset that people are not being ushered into America. They think that it is not right for immigrants to be stopped, and seem shocked that this is happening. However, they should not be shocked, because that is the law of the land. The law does not just change like this. If the law is unjust, then it should be changed through the legislative process. Another group of people who is upset over the caravan being stopped at the border is the city of Tijuana. The city is losing 30-40 thousand dollars a day housing all of the caravan members there, and the mayor is not happy about it. According to Fox News, he says there will be no more funding for the caravan, and has given the order to arrest the organizer of the caravan. The city "lost 129 million pesos" while the border was closed for 6 hours on Sunday (Fox News). The people in the caravan have absolutely no right to do that to the city of Tijuana and its 1.7 million taxpayers.
      I think that the people who are stating their opinions on these things should look at the facts before they say anything, because then they might end up looking foolish for saying there is no way to know if there are bad people in the caravan that has been proven to have bad people in it (MS-13). They need to look at the situation and see what the reality is before they trash talk anybody else for being correct.

2 comments:

  1. i decided to comment on my class mate Paul’s post I agree with a lot of what he had to say, while I’m not a trump supporter I completely agree that people shouldn’t give him shit for saying that there could possibly be someone dangerous in the caravan. That’s his job he needs to worry for his citizens and avoid harm at all costs he’s trying to protect his country from strangers. Next he talks about Tijuana loosing a lot of money due to having all these strangers stay in the border until they decide what happens to them. I believe that they need to leave the border because, they are invading people’s homes, daily lives etc. while I understand why they left their countries they didn’t think the whole situation out correctly. Due to them not thinking it through many people are paying for their mistakes which is ridiculous they shouldn’t have to.

    ReplyDelete
  2. In this Post I want to respond to Paul Stanglin and his post about the migrant caravan and the medias criticisms of Trump. I am going comment in the order he laid out his arguments.
    In his post, Stanglin, discusses the media bashing of Trump’s handling of the migrant caravan. He defends Trump by reiterating the “there are likely bad people in the caravan”, to which I would ask what does It matter. We shouldn’t condemn the many for the actions of a few. It is this kind of bigotry and ignorance that is being attacked and bashed by the media. The problem people have with this kind of rhetoric is it isn’t reciprocated when there is a white person who does a crime and this kind of cherry-picking articles and instances where this may be true is the reason people like Tucker Carlson exist. The simple fact is that you can find an article and events to drive any kind of message you so choose to convey. There may be some bad people in this country however I wouldn’t generalize the whole country as murderers. This kind of generalization.is what creates stereotypes and feeds racism. We as a society need to become independent thinkers and learn how to take in multiple points of views from different background and use those to formulate an opinion of our own.
    In addition to the media bashing, Stanglin goes on to say it is the “law of the land” as the reason the caravan is being stopped at the border. It was once legal to own slaves, laws don’t dictate morality and it is our moral duty to help these people. This idea that want to let immigrants in to the country legally is simply false, nobody believes people should be able to walk into the country without proper paperwork. The thing we do disagree on is the way in which we allow people into the country. The people in the caravan aren’t simply coming to the country because they feel like it, they are here seeking asylum from their respective countries. The fact of the matter is this wouldn’t even be reported by the news or talked about if these immigrants were white and coming from Canada.
    Furthermore, Stanglin ends his argument by pleading with people to “look at the facts” when he himself used one source for all his supporting data, Fox News. I’m not going to bash Fox News however I am going to draw attention to the fact Stanglin is asking for people to get all the facts however he himself is getting the facts from one very conservative source. Limiting yourself to one source especially one that is notorious for leaning conservative diminishes his credibility. It doesn’t bother me his opinion and political views are different than however I hope he would’ve come in this post with a more open-minded attitude and demeanor.

    ReplyDelete